Common Cents – Tax Day
There are only three things that I know a lot about: the
Bible, photography, and taxes. I also have opinions about music and cars. For
the price of a cup of coffee, I will talk all day about music and cars. If you
want to talk about the Bible, I will buy. But for taxes and photography, I like
to get paid.
Since April 15 is Tax Day, and almost a national holiday,
let’s talk tax for free. First, taxes are often due a different day than April
15 because of weekends, holidays, or just because the IRS needs more time. The
due date this year is May 17, except for the estimated tax due date which
remain April 15. The drop-dead, jigs-up
due date, as always, is October 15.
I have been a business owner since I was sixteen in 1964. I
got serious about running a business to support my family in 1973. That means I
have had forty-eight years of hands-on business experience. I decided early on
that I would not let the tax code cloud otherwise good decisions. It is
important to understand taxes but letting the IRS and tax laws dictate how our
business operates is a bad idea.
The tax laws change frequently and almost always for
political reasons. A tax-motivated decision this year may be a bad decision
next year.
For example, owning a home is the most common way for
middle-class Americans to build wealth. Buying a house when we can afford to do
so is a great idea. Buying a house because we can deduct the mortgage interest
and property tax to save money on taxes is a bad idea. I have had many tax
clients who were excited about the big refund promised by a realtor because
they bought a house this year, only to find that it made no real difference, usually
because the standard deduction was greater than their mortgage and property tax
deduction. The standard deduction and even the deductibility of interest change
regularly. Making charitable donations are always a good use of resources but
doing so just for the tax deduction is always a bad idea. Either we have a
desire to give, or we don’t. A tax deduction might be a bonus, but it should
not be a motivator. Having a baby to get another exemption or child tax credit
is not good long-range planning.
That does not mean we can ignore tax implications of our
decisions. A few years ago, I had a tax client who cashed in a large IRA to buy
into a retirement community. An IRA distribution is taxed as ordinary income so
she had less for this purchase after paying tax on the investment. She then
sold her home of many years, much of which went to pay the taxes on the IRA
distribution. The sale of the house was tax exempt. If she had waited to buy
into the retirement community until she sold her home, or even taken a home
equity loan until the house sold instead of cashing in the IRA, she would have
saved tens of thousands of dollars in taxes.
Small timing adjustments can make a big difference too. For
example, if we are nearing retirement, we must not take money from our IRA or
pension account the same calendar year as our salary or retirement bonus.
Waiting until the next year could put us in a lower bracket, especially in the
amount of tax on Social Security. The taxable amount of Social Security is
dependent on other income for that year. If our only income is Social Security,
it is tax free. A big IRA or pension withdrawal will likely make 85% of Social
Security taxable. This is huge for the average taxpayer. If we have a choice of
December or January to take the money, wait until January.
Taxes don’t have to be burdensome or challenging, but they
require a little thought and research to determine the best strategy each tax
season. When in doubt, consult a tax professional for the best way to navigate
these financial waters.